Fortune | FORTUNE 10月04日
AI热潮是否会重演科技泡沫?分析师认为当前情况不同
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

尽管AI领域的狂热和高估值引发了对科技泡沫的担忧,但分析师指出,当前情况与互联网泡沫时期存在显著差异。标普500指数成分股的盈利预期正在上升,市盈率并未达到历史高位,且大型科技公司的估值甚至有所回落。此外,美联储正在降息而非加息,这与2000年形成了鲜明对比。虽然未来可能出现调整,但AI技术革命的潜力依然巨大,其发展基础比20年前更为稳固,许多AI相关企业盈利强劲。

📈 **盈利增长与估值差异**: 与互联网泡沫时期不同,当前标普500指数成分股的盈利预期正在上升,特别是“大科技”领域。市盈率(价格/预期未来十二个月每股收益)的增长幅度有限,甚至低于互联网泡沫破裂前夕的水平。这表明市场上涨有其基本面支撑,而非纯粹的投机。

🏦 **宏观经济环境对比**: 当前的货币政策环境与2000年截然不同。彼时美联储在加息以抑制过热的经济,而现在则处于降息周期。这种宽松的货币政策有助于支撑市场,并与互联网泡沫破裂前的紧缩环境形成鲜明对比,降低了市场“脱轨”的风险。

💡 **企业盈利能力增强**: 相比之下,当前科技公司,特别是为AI热潮提供关键支持的芯片制造商(如英伟达、台积电),盈利能力强劲。尽管一些初创公司可能面临挑战,但与互联网泡沫时期大量亏损的初创企业不同,当前亏损的科技和电信公司比例显著降低,显示出更健康的商业模式。

🚀 **AI技术的长期潜力**: 尽管存在短期泡沫的担忧,AI技术被普遍认为具有像互联网一样的革命性潜力。虽然其普及速度和影响方式可能超出预期,但技术本身的价值和发展前景依然光明。市场更关注的是技术采纳的速度和有效性,而非技术本身的失败。

Relentless stock-market highs, astronomical valuations for OpenAI, and reports of hyperscalers taking on more debt have stoked fears that the AI boom is another tech bubble ready to pop.

Even OpenAI CEO Sam Altman acknowledged this summer that investors were getting “overexcited about AI” and drew parallels with the dot-com bubble.

But Capital Economics pointed out that year-ahead earnings forecasts for S&P 500 companies—forward-twelve-month (FTM) earnings per share (EPS)—are rising and underpin the stock market rally.

“Although this has mainly reflected developments in the ‘big-tech’ sectors, which have collectively continued to experience phenomenal earnings growth, FTM EPS have also picked up in the rest of the index,” Capital Economics’ chief markets economist John Higgins wrote in a note Monday.

Meanwhile, the ratio of stock prices to earnings estimates has barely increased, edging up to roughly 22.6 from about 22.3 at the start of this year, he added.

And in fact, the ratio for big tech stocks, which have been driving the market surge, has actually dipped marginally.

“The upshot is that price/FTM earnings ratios—for the S&P 500; the big-tech sectors combined; and the rest of the index—are still not as high as they were when the dotcom bubble burst,” Higgins said.

Another key difference between now and the earlier boom-bust era is that the Federal Reserve is lowering rates instead of raising them, though it’s not clear how aggressive the current easing cycle will be.

To be sure, Capital Economics still sees a big correction hitting the S&P 500 eventually, once the AI hype in the stock market has peaked.

But Higgins said that may not happen before 2027. At the same time, the AI boom is transforming the economy.

“And the economy more generally doesn’t look as soft as some recent labor market data have suggested,” he added. “Finally, the bond market would be more likely to come seriously unstuck if the Fed tightened policy, as it did in 1999/2000. This time around, the central bank looks set to do the opposite.”

Similarly, Oxford Economics also noted this week that the current boom has better fundamentals than the dot-com days. The price-to-earnings ratio for tech stocks today is just 56% of what it was at the peak of the dot-com bubble, according to a note Tuesday. And for chip stocks, it’s even lower at 43%.

The dot-com bubble was also marked by investors throwing money at startups with little or no earnings, only to see those bets backfire. But Oxford Economics said just 4% of the tech and telecom firms in the S&P 500 are making a loss versus 12% just before the dot-com bubble popped.

And while OpenAI is not yet profitable, chipmakers like Nvidia and TSMC supplying the AI boom are awash in earnings amid high demand.

Aside from the current stock valuations, the bigger picture for AI is that the technology still promises to usher in a revolution, similar to what the internet did, it added.

“There are certainly many firms that could not secure their share of the market, but the technology itself never failed to take off. It just took longer than people initially expected,” Oxford pointed out. “We expect a similar outcome for AI in the end, but how bumpy the road ahead will depend on the pace and the effectiveness of the technology uptake.”

Fortune Global Forum

returns Oct. 26–27, 2025 in Riyadh. CEOs and global leaders will gather for a dynamic, invitation-only event shaping the future of business.

Apply for an invitation.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

AI泡沫 科技泡沫 人工智能 股票市场 估值 宏观经济 AI Boom Tech Bubble Artificial Intelligence Stock Market Valuation Macroeconomics
相关文章