Now, as president and chief commercial officer of Wayfair, Blotner says his long-running operating system is reflected in how he leads today. He hires for horsepower and humility, then sets teams on outcomes that matter. He prefers hypothesis-led debate that moves decisions forward and builds alignment by co-authoring plans with his leaders, documenting them, and disseminating them across the company. “I try to focus not on whether my idea wins but on chasing the right idea,” Blotner says. He also evaluates managers on whether they develop other managers, considering leadership depth a core advantage.

Blotner joined Wayfair in 2016, just two years after its initial public offering, and has rotated roles approximately every two years. His remit has expanded across brand and performance marketing, global logistics, and data science. What’s carried him, he says, is curiosity, humility, and the discipline to ask for help quickly. “For me to really be engaged, it has to be something that I feel a part of and responsible for,” he says.

One early assignment set the template. Blotner was charged with scaling Wayfair’s proprietary brands and onboarding new suppliers to broaden the selection—a challenge that required blending merchandising, taxonomy, and systems thinking. Missteps followed when supplier capacity lagged or products were misclassified in ways that confused shoppers. The fix became a playbook he still uses: set a multiyear vision, break it into three- and six-month checkpoints, and meet regularly with the full team to spot drag and pivot fast.

The pandemic stress-tested those instincts. Wayfair overhired as homebound consumers snapped up furniture, then faced a sharp slowdown in demand. Blotner led efforts to strip away layers that slowed decisions, stretch strong performers, and continue investing in growth areas, such as the company’s first-party logistics network, physical retail, and a new paid loyalty program. That logistics buildout now allows large items to arrive in days, with assembly and haul-away included, providing a competitive edge in a category notorious for long wait times.

Physical retail is Wayfair’s next major wager, with 12 stores already open and three more under lease. Wayfair has a flagship store in Chicago and a growing fleet of stores under banners including AllModern, Joss & Main, Birch Lane, and the luxury marketplace Perigold. Each location must perform on its own economics while generating a “halo effect” in surrounding zip codes. In Chicago, local Wayfair sales increased after the store opened, as shoppers discovered the brand in person and then made purchases online. The national warehouse footprint gives stores another advantage: faster delivery than legacy furniture timelines and a seamless shopping cart experience across channels.

Of course, macro pressures remain. Housing turnover shapes demand, and tariffs ripple through supply chains. Wayfair’s answer is a diversified supplier base across North America and Asia, the ability to shift assortment as costs fluctuate, and tactical promotions in partnership with vendors, says Blotner. However, he notes that its scale in logistics and breadth of marketplace cushion shocks that would rattle smaller rivals.

Blotner’s own north star is expanding scope without losing speed. He says he still treats career management as a function of where the hardest problems sit and whether the team around him raises the average. Titles don’t drive him, he adds, impact does. And with the home furnishings market still largely fragmented, Blotner sees ample opportunity to continue growing its share if the company can maintain the autonomy, urgency, and appetite for complexity that brought him to its C-suite in the first place.