Fortune | FORTUNE 09月23日 16:11
高规格纪念活动安保严密,耗资巨大
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

周日的纪念活动由美国总统、副总统及五名内阁成员发表讲话,活动被定为一级特殊活动评估(SEAR Level 1),其安保措施和成本堪比超级碗。亚利桑那州格伦代尔的州立农场体育场座无虚席,约有7万名观众,附近的沙漠钻石体育馆也容纳了1万名观众。国际安全专家表示,此次活动是美国近代史上安保最严密的纪念活动之一,从空中到地面,各方面都设置了严密的安保层级。高调的安保措施包括防弹玻璃、金属探测器、安全围栏、道路封闭、车辆检查以及大量的执法和私人安保人员。此外,还部署了反狙击小组、便衣警察、反无人机系统,并对排水系统进行封堵,以应对各种潜在威胁。专家估计,此次活动的安保费用可能高达数百万美元。然而,活动中的烟花表演引发了争议,许多人认为其更多是形式而非实际安全贡献。

活动被评定为SEAR Level 1,安保级别极高,成本接近超级碗,吸引了约8万名观众参加,显示了其重要性和规模。

安保措施极为严密,包括舞台上的防弹玻璃、金属探测器、安全围栏、道路封闭、车辆检查、反狙击小组、便衣警察以及反无人机系统等,确保了活动的安全进行。

专家估计此次活动的安保费用高达数百万美元,尽管是一场私营性质的活动,但SEAR 1评级调动了联邦层面的协调和支持。

活动中使用的烟花表演引发了争议,专家认为其更多是形式上的“粉丝”效果,而非实质性的安全保障,尤其是在有防弹玻璃等更有效的防护措施存在的情况下。

The event on Sunday included remarks from President Donald Trump, Vice President JD Vance, and five members of the Cabinet. The lineup called for a Special Event Assessment Rating (SEAR) Level 1, prompting security measures and a price tag on par with a Super Bowl. And State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Ariz., was filled to capacity with about 70,000, while a nearby overflow site at Desert Diamond Arena held 10,000.

Toby Braun, international security expert and founder of American Special Investigative Group, told Fortune the event was “one of the most fortified memorial services in recent U.S. history,” with security layers in every aspect of the environment, from the airspace above the venue to the streets below.

Highly-visible measures included the transparent ballistic glass onstage designed to resist both gunfire and explosive blasts, TSA-like magnetometer checkpoints, security fencing, road closures, and vehicle checkpoints—and a massive amount of both law enforcement and private security personnel, he said.

Other measures included counter-sniper teams monitoring potential long-range threats from elevated positions, plain-clothes officers mingled in with the crowds to identify suspicious behavior, anti-drone systems shielding the venue from aerial threats—even though its retractable roof was shut for the event—and law enforcement drones of their own.

Additionally, explosive detection equipment, K9 sweeps, and sealed drainage openings along motorcade routes added further layers of protection to guard against unconventional attack methods, Braun added.

The bulletproof glass was reminiscent of the Popemobile, Eric O’Neill, former FBI counterterrorism and counterintelligence operative, told Fortune, adding the security measure may become the “new future” for political speakers, especially those that can’t afford a Secret Security detail. During his campaign in August 2024, Trump spoke behind a bulletproof glass enclosure in Asheboro, N. C., five weeks after an assassination attempt in Butler, Penn.

All said, the measures likely cost taxpayers an amount comparable to a Super Bowl security bill, O’Neill estimated. Even though ​​the stadium authority stressed it was a private event, the SEAR 1 rating mobilizes federal coordination teams and interagency support under DHS and the Secret Service.

There is no official public estimate of the cost of Kirk’s memorial, and DHS did not respond to questions on estimated costs for the event.

“It’s so hard to estimate costs… every city is different,” Braun said. “But it cost millions.”

Contentious fireworks

But one feature of the ceremony sparked debate over its actual contribution to security. Fireworks spouted directly beyond the stage where the president and others spoke, which had online critics questioning the need for them. Some experts tell Fortune the pyrotechnics were more fanfare than threat prevention.

“I thought that was more to make it seem a little bit more like a tent revival,” O’Neill said.

He pointed out that a rarely used bulletproof glass shield enclosing the speaker podium protected anyone onstage more than fireworks ever would. The case for the pyrotechnics providing an added layer of protection was moot when the high-profile leaders moved in and out of the enclosed area between speeches—plus the fact that the fireworks didn’t spark continuously throughout the ceremony—O’Neill added.

Using fireworks to distract or impair a potential shooter’s vision is a “clever” take, but probably wouldn’t have an impact, especially compared to the bulletproof glass that would presumably stop a bullet, O’Neill said.

Richard Bradshaw, director of Rebel Safety, a specialist safety consultancy for film, TV and live events, told Fortune it would be challenging to demonstrate how fireworks reduce risk in a crowded or emotionally sensitive environment.

“Pyrotechnics are usually designed for visual impact, not for addressing security threats,” he said.

Fortune Global Forum

returns Oct. 26–27, 2025 in Riyadh. CEOs and global leaders will gather for a dynamic, invitation-only event shaping the future of business.

Apply for an invitation.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

纪念活动 安保 SEAR Level 1 防弹玻璃 烟花 Memorial Event Security SEAR Level 1 Ballistic Glass Fireworks
相关文章