n8n Blog 09月18日
AI自主代理:权衡自主性与可控性
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

文章探讨了完全自主AI代理的吸引力及其潜在的隐藏成本。虽然为特定任务构建有人工干预的代理相对容易,但真正的自主系统意味着将控制权交给大型语言模型(LLMs),而LLMs可能以意想不到的方式偏离最佳路径。因此,企业面临着如何在自主性和可控性之间进行权衡的根本性问题。不同的业务场景需要不同的安全措施,有些流程受益于完全自主,而另一些则需要战略性的人工检查点。文章 review 了12种不同的自主AI代理,并展示了n8n等平台如何实现自定义自主工作流,让用户精确控制AI代理的独立性。

🤖 **自主AI代理的定义与核心特征**:自主AI代理与传统AI代理的关键区别在于其自主性水平。传统代理遵循预设规则,而自主代理能独立设定目标、规划多步骤任务、适应环境变化并集成工具以达成目标,即使在复杂多变的场景下也能独立运作,但同时也带来了不可预测性。

⚖️ **自主性与可控性的权衡**:文章强调,完全自主AI代理并非万能。企业需要在AI的自主执行能力与必要的人工监督之间找到平衡点。例如,法律合同审查需要严格的合规性检查,而销售数据优化则可能受益于更广泛的自主探索。这种权衡并非一成不变,而是取决于具体的业务需求和风险承受能力。

🛠️ **多样化的自主AI代理工具**:文章列举了12种不同的自主AI代理,涵盖了从无代码构建器(如Lindy AI)到专注于特定行业(如Harvey AI用于法律,Clay用于销售)的专业工具,再到开发者用于构建自定义系统的基础设施级工具(如VAPI)。这反映了当前市场上自主AI代理的多样化发展方向和应用场景。

🌐 **n8n等平台提供的灵活自主性**:文章特别提到n8n等自动化平台,它们允许用户构建自定义的自主工作流,精确控制AI代理的自主程度。这为企业提供了在享受AI带来的效率提升的同时,又能确保关键环节得到有效监督的解决方案,实现了“灵活自主,由你掌控”。

The promise of fully autonomous AI agents sounds appealing: just set a goal and let AI handle everything.

In reality, complete autonomy often comes with a hidden cost.

While it’s relatively straightforward to build human-in-the-loop agents for specific tasks, creating truly autonomous systems means surrendering control to LLMs. And despite their capabilities, LLMs can deviate from the optimal path in countless unexpected ways.

This leads to a fundamental tradeoff that every business faces: how much autonomy do you actually want, and how much oversight can you realistically provide?

The answer isn’t universal. A legal firm reviewing contracts needs different guardrails than a sales team enriching prospect data. Some workflows benefit from full autonomy, while others require strategic human checkpoints.

In this guide, we review 12 autonomous AI agents that handle this tradeoff in different ways – from simple no-code builders to sophisticated systems that operate independently for hours on end.

We also show you how platforms like n8n let you build custom autonomous workflows where you control exactly how much independence you want to grant your AI agents.

Table of contents

What are autonomous AI agents?

The main difference between traditional AI agents and autonomous ones lies in the level of human oversight required to define and execute objectives.

Consider a customer service chatbot that follows your predefined rules and forwards complex issues to humans. It’s helpful, but it operates within the strict boundaries you’ve set.

Now imagine an AI system tasked with “increasing customer retention by 15%.” A truly autonomous version would independently analyze your customer data, identify at-risk segments, design retention campaigns, and execute them across multiple channels – without asking for permission at every step.

This level of independence can deliver impressive results, but it also leads to unpredictability. The agent might choose strategies you wouldn’t have considered, access data in unexpected ways, or interpret “success” differently than you intended.

Most successful implementations today operate somewhere in the middle—autonomous enough to handle complex multi-step tasks, but with strategic human oversight at critical decision points.

Core characteristics of autonomous AI agents

Autonomous AI agents share several key characteristics that distinguish them from traditional automation:

Difference from traditional AI agents

FeatureAI AgentsAutonomous AI Agents
Autonomy LevelPartialFull or near-full
Task ComplexitySingle or simple workflowsComplex, evolving
multi-step plans
Human SupervisionFrequent or requiredMinimal or optional
AdaptabilityLowHigh
Planning & ReasoningRule-based or reactiveGoal-directed and strategic

Key autonomous AI agents use cases

Autonomous AI agents excel in scenarios where human supervision would slow down complex, multi-step processes. Here are the most common areas of application:

12 top autonomous AI agents of 2025

The autonomous AI agent landscape includes hundreds of specialized tools. We’ve curated 12 agents that represent different approaches to the autonomy challenge.

Our selection follows a progression: we start with user-friendly business-focused agents that anyone can deploy quickly. Then we move into specialized agents built for specific industries like legal or sales. Finally, we explore infrastructure-level tools that developers use to build custom autonomous systems from the ground up.

This selection reflects the variety of approaches currently being tested across different industries and use cases.

ToolCategoryTarget AudiencePrimary Use Cases
Lindy AINo-Code agent builderBusiness usersWorkflow automation,
customer service,
lead generation
Relevance AIMulti-agent platformEnterprise teamsMulti-agent workflows,
business process automation
Harvey AILegal AI agentsLegal professionalsLegal document review,
contract analysis,
compliance
ClaySales enrichmentSales teamsSales prospecting,
data enrichment,
outreach personalization
HubSpot
Breeze
CRM AI agentsHubSpot usersMarketing, sales,
customer service
automation within HubSpot
SalesCloser AISales automationSales teamsAutomated sales conversations,
lead qualification
VAPIVoice AI infrastructureDevelopersVoice AI applications,
phone automation,
conversational interfaces
Box AI AgentsDocument AI agentsEnterprise
document
management
Document analysis,
content management,
enterprise search
Browserbase
Director
Browser automationDevelopers/
automation teams
Web scraping,
browser automation,
testing
legacy-useLegacy system
integration
Enterprise ITLegacy system
API modernization
DroidrunMobile automationMobile app developersAndroid device automation,
mobile testing
Claude CodeCoding assistantSoftware developersAutonomous coding,
code review,
development automation

Lindy AI

A no-code platform that lets you build AI agents by describing tasks in English, with a drag-and-drop interface.

Lindy allows creating simple agents with basic business features

Distinctive features: Lindy allows you to create AI-employees in minutes and add components with typical tasks such as a phone call, email or calendar. The platform also offers access to a template marketplace where you can select pre-built agents for common tasks.

Strengths:

Ideal users: Small businesses and non-technical teams who want automation without the complexity - perfect for customer support, lead nurturing and meeting scheduling.

Pricing: Starting at $50/month for 5,000 credits, with a free tier that offers 400 credits per month for basic actions to test the waters.

Relevance AI

A multi-agent platform where teams of specialized AI agents collaborate on complex workflows, applying advanced chain-of-thought reasoning.

Relevance AI focuses on multi-agent interactions

Distinctive features: Unlike single-agent platforms, Relevance AI deploys multiple agents that work together - think of it as hiring an entire AI department rather than just one assistant. The platform includes agent-to-agent communication protocols and dynamic task allocation among team members.

Strengths

Ideal users: Enterprise teams handling complex business processes that require multiple specialized skills - like research pipelines, content generation workflows, or multi-stage sales processes.

Pricing: Starting at $19/month for 10,000 credits, with enterprise plans offering custom pricing and dedicated infrastructure.

Harvey AI

Legal-specific AI agents designed exclusively for law firms, with built-in understanding of legal processes and jurisdiction variations.

Harvey offers several features optimized for lawyers

Distinctive features: Unlike general-purpose platforms such as Lindy or Relevance AI, Harvey is specifically designed for legal tasks. It understands attorney-client privilege, ensures compliance across different jurisdictions, and integrates directly into legal practice management systems.

Strengths

Ideal users: Law firms and corporate legal departments involved in contract review, legal research, due diligence, and compliance monitoring - areas where legal accuracy is essential.

Pricing: Enterprise-only with custom pricing.

Clay

Sales intelligence platform where AI agents autonomously research prospects and enrich data by combining information from 50+ sources.

Clay works like a smart AI-powered spreadsheet

Distinctive features: While Harvey AI specializes in legal tasks, Clay focuses entirely on sales intelligence. Its “waterfall enrichment” feature automatically tries multiple data sources until it finds the information you need and can perform complex web searches that go far beyond what CRM-integrated tools like HubSpot Breeze offer.

Strengths

Ideal users: Sales teams and revenue operations that need thorough prospect research and account-based marketing - especially those handling high-value B2B sales where personalization matters.

Pricing: Starting at $149/month for 2,000 credits, with usage-based pricing that scales based on your research volume.

HubSpot Breeze

CRM-integrated AI agents that work natively within HubSpot’s ecosystem, covering prospecting, customer service, content creation and social media management.

Hubspot Breeze integrates autonomous agents inside the platform UI

Distinctive features: Unlike standalone platforms like Clay or Lindy which require separate integrations, Breeze agents live directly inside HubSpot. You get multiple specialized agents - for prospecting, customer service, content, and social media - all sharing the same customer data without having to worry about setup.

Strengths

Ideal users: HubSpot customers who want AI automation without the complexity of managing multiple tools - perfect for marketing and sales teams already invested in the HubSpot ecosystem.

Pricing: Breeze uses HubSpot Credits which are included in every seat-based tier. Additional packs begin from $10/mo for 1000 credits.

Salescloser AI

Conversational AI that handles complete sales conversations autonomously across email, chat, SMS, and phone channels.

Salescloser has a rather basic UI, where users can describe transitions in plain language

Distinctive features: While HubSpot Breeze works within your existing CRM, Salescloser focuses exclusively on actual sales conversations. It can qualify leads through natural dialogue, handle objections, and book appointments - essentially replacing your SDR team rather than just supporting it like Clay’s research agents do.

Strengths

Ideal users: SMBs and lead generation companies that need to scale their sales conversations without hiring more staff - especially effective for qualifying inbound leads and scheduling appointments.

Pricing: Available upon request.

VAPI

Voice AI infrastructure platform that provides the building blocks for creating conversational voice applications with a response time of less than 500 ms.

Vapi allows creating agents within a single screen

Distinctive features: Unlike conversation-oriented tools such as Salescloser which cover specific sales scenarios, VAPI is purely infrastructure - think of it as the voice equivalent of what n8n does for workflow automation. It offers real-time webhook integration during actual calls, making it perfect for building custom voice agents that can be connected with other automation platforms.

Strengths

Ideal users: Developers and businesses building voice-enabled applications - from customer service phone automation to accessibility applications that require a reliable voice infrastructure.

Pricing: Usage-based between $0.05-0.20 per minute, depending on the model, so you only pay for actual conversation time.

Box AI Agents

AI for enterprise document management that provides intelligent search, automatic classification, and workflow automation across organizational content.

Box.com focuses on agents for company document processing

Distinctive features: Box AI Agents specialize entirely in document intelligence within enterprise environments. Unlike general-purpose platforms, these agents understand document hierarchies, compliance requirements and can automatically enforce retention policies across large content repositories.

Strengths

Ideal users: Large organizations with complex document workflows, compliance requirements, and knowledge management needs - particularly useful for contract lifecycle management and regulatory reporting.

Pricing: Included when purchasing Box Enterprise Plus / Enterprise Advanced plans, with additional AI units for high-volume usage.

Browserbase Director

An LLM-powered browser automation platform that generates reproducible scripts from natural language instructions and is built on a scalable cloud infrastructure.

Director generates reusable browser automation scripts

Distinctive features: Browserbase Director is a new product for creating web automations using AI. Unlike traditional browser automation which requires coding skills, Director lets you describe what you want in a text field and generates reusable scripts - bridging the gap between no-code simplicity and developer-grade reliability.

Strengths

Ideal users: Developers and automation engineers who need sophisticated web scraping or automated testing - especially those building workflows that integrate with platforms like n8n.

Pricing: Director is free to create automations, but Browserbase's standard rates apply for execution: staring at $20/month for the Developer Plan.

Legacy-use

An open-source tool that automatically creates REST APIs for legacy systems without requiring changes to existing applications.

Legacy-use automates old Windows apps inside VM environments

Distinctive features: While other tools focus on modern integrations, legacy-use solves the problem that many enterprises face - connecting decades-old systems with modern AI workflows. It uses multimodal LLMs to understand legacy interfaces and automatically generate API endpoints, making it possible to include old Windows software in your automation pipelines.

Strengths

Ideal users: Enterprise IT teams and system integrators dealing with legacy applications or older ERP systems that need to be connected with modern tools and workflows.

Pricing: Open-source with free community edition, plus commercial support and enterprise features available for complex deployments.

Droidrun

Open-source framework that enables LLM-driven automation of Android devices.

Droidrun allows automating both physical devices or virtual phones

Distinctive features: While legacy-use modernizes old desktop software, Droidrun brings AI automation to mobile devices. It can control both physical and virtual Android devices using computer vision and natural language processing - essentially giving you an AI assistant that can navigate mobile apps just like a human.

Strengths

Ideal users: Mobile developers and QA engineers who need to automate app testing, user behavior simulation, or accessibility testing across different Android devices and app versions.

Pricing: Open-source and free to use, with upcoming cloud platform options for large-scale mobile automation.

Claude Code

Anthropic’s official autonomous coding agent that handles complete feature development from natural language descriptions, with built-in CI/CD automation via GitHub Actions.

Claude Code is an advanced CLI utility that can orchestrate multiple coding agents

Distinctive features: While Claude models already support popular coding agents like Cursor and Aider, Anthropic now offers its own CLI tool. Compared to these alternatives,  Claude Code enables more autonomous operation - it requires less manual oversight when handling multi-step development tasks from planning to deployment.

Strengths

Ideal users: Software developers and teams who want to automate feature development, code refactoring, and test creation - especially valuable for teams that want to focus on architecture while AI handles the implementation details.

Pricing: Included in the Claude Pro subscription for $20/month or the Teams plan for $25/month. Also available via API with usage-based pricing.

Building fully autonomous AI agents with n8n

The agents we’ve reviewed solve certain tasks well, but what if you need something that’s better tailored to your business?

Perhaps you need an agent that processes invoices, updates your CRM, sends Slack notifications, and forwards complex cases to humans – all based on your exact business rules. Or maybe you want to combine multiple AI capabilities while maintaining control over when the agent acts independently and when it asks for approval.

This is where n8n becomes essential for building autonomous agents that work exactly the way you need them to:

Building fully autonomous AI agents with n8n

Flexible autonomy, your way

With n8n, you can precisely control how autonomous your AI agents become. You can build anything from fully autonomous systems that run for hours without human intervention to agentic workflows that combine AI decision-making with strategic human oversight.

The platform supports multiple triggers for hundreds of services, as well as webhooks, schedules, file changes, database updates – so your agents can automatically spring into action based on real-world events. And with n8n’s visual canvas, you can easily add human-in-the-loop checkpoints wherever you need them.

💡
Pro tip: n8n also integrates with existing agents through MCP (Model Context Protocol) servers, and you can expose your workflows as tools that external agents can trigger directly.

Recent n8n updates make autonomous agents more reliable

Several recent n8n features are specifically designed to address the challenges of building production-ready autonomous agents:

Building your first autonomous agent in n8n

Creating an AI agent in n8n is a straightforward process:

    Start with a trigger that fits your use case (webhook, schedule, database change, etc.)Add an AI Agent node connected to your chosen LLMEquip it with custom tools for specific actions – web scrapers, database queries, API calls, file processors

If necessary:

💡
Our recommendation: start with a pre-built agent that covers 80% of your use case, then see if the remaining 20% justifies the development of a custom solution. For most businesses, that threshold comes faster than expected.

Here’s a 2-part series on creating AI agents:

Explore community-built agents in the template gallery:

Wrap up

We explored 12 autonomous AI agents covering a vast automation spectrum:

Most excel in their niches—but what if you need an agent that processes invoices, updates multiple systems, and routes complex cases to the right people?

That’s where n8n comes in: it lets you build fully autonomous agents that combine multiple capabilities with the exact level of human oversight you want, while integrating seamlessly with specialized tools for advanced needs.

Ready to experience the difference autonomous agents can make?

Build an agent that works exactly how your business needs it to!

What’s next?

Ready to dive deeper into the world of autonomous AI agents? Here are your next steps:

Finally, explore n8n’s AI ecosystem and browse the community AI workflows to see what’s possible when you have complete control over your autonomous agent architecture.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

Autonomous AI Agents AI Agents LLMs Automation Workflow Automation AI Control n8n AI Trade-offs AI in Business AI Agents Review
相关文章