Fortune | FORTUNE 09月18日
大学教育价值引争议,AI时代下对未来职业规划的思考
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

当前,以Gen Z为代表的年轻一代对大学教育的价值产生了质疑,甚至认为其可能是一种“骗局”。科技行业高管David Krane分享了其儿子在AI领域实习的经历,以及他与同龄人在思考大学教育投入与回报时的困惑。LinkedIn的调查显示,专业人士对大学学位必要性的看法存在分歧,尤其是在技术领域,技能优先的招聘模式可能扩大就业机会。然而,AI的发展也对计算机科学等领域造成冲击,一些专家认为,虽然AI工具易于使用,但深层理解和应用仍需人类的专业知识和批判性思维。教育界人士指出,AI时代下,深入学习和建立专业知识比以往任何时候都更加重要,而大学教育也在向更灵活、模块化和技能导向的方向发展。

🎓 Gen Z群体对大学教育的价值产生质疑,他们开始思考教育投入是否值得,以及是否应该承担额外的债务来获取学位,尤其是在AI等领域存在快速学习和实践机会的情况下。

📊 职场招聘趋势正转向“技能优先”模式。LinkedIn调查显示,只有约41%的初级专业人士认为大学学位是职业成功的必需品,而技能导向的招聘能显著扩大潜在人才库,尤其是在科技和媒体行业。

💻 AI技术的发展对传统计算机科学领域带来了挑战,但同时也催生了新的机遇。专家指出,AI工具的普及并不意味着人类专业知识的过时,理解代码的效率、安全和道德性仍需人类的洞察力,而深度学习和专业知识在AI应用领域更为关键。

📚 大学教育正在经历转型,以适应AI时代的需求。未来的教育模式将更加灵活、模块化,并与市场实际所需的技能紧密结合,强调深入学习和构建坚实的理论基础,以应对未来技术的发展。

💡 尽管存在争议,但专家认为,在AI时代,拥有扎实的学科基础(如数学和计算机科学)对于深入理解和开发AI系统至关重要。大学学位仍然具有价值,但获取学位的方式正变得更加多样化和适应性强。

Gen Z is debating whether college is still worth it—and it’s a conversation even GV’s CEO David Krane has had at the dinner table.

Krane’s oldest son, who’s halfway through college, is among the Gen Zers questioning the value of a college degree, the executive told Fortune during the Brainstorm Tech conference in Park City, Utah, last week.

“He’s at a liberal arts university on the East Coast in the United States, and he’s asking himself real questions—even bluntly: ‘Is this education a scam?’” Krane told the audience.

Krane, who was employee number 84 at Google, explained that his son spent the entire summer working in AI with large language models and coding assistants. 

“He spent the last month of his summer spending a lot of time with peers at Ivy League schools and other notable undergraduate programs who are wrestling with exactly that tension,” Krane said.

Krane said Gen Zers are asking themselves: “Is this education worth it? Do I want to take on additional debt? Can I go build now? Because there’s certainly people that will back me and give me a little bit of capital to begin to figure those questions out.”

The value of a college degree

Hiring professionals are asking similar questions.

Only 41% of junior U.S. professionals say a college degree is necessary for career success, according to a new LinkedIn Workforce Confidence survey. Director-level professionals skew higher, with 47% saying degrees are essential. The survey spans fields including real estate, financial services, and education, saying a skills-first hiring approach would, on average, broaden talent pools in the U.S. by nearly 16 times

Gen Zers looking for work in tech, like Krane’s son, could see higher return on investing in skills than the average. The tech and media industry, for example, stands to gain more from a skills-first hiring approach, with potential to broaden the talent pool by 24 times, according to the survey.

However, the computer science field for recent graduates has been significantly impacted by AI, resulting in fewer job opportunities and even making it challenging for high-skilled job seekers to secure an interview. 

Experts tell Fortune that as companies adopt AI, workers who utilize the technology daily often don’t have an education in coding.

“Based on the data we see helping 10,000 companies like Boeing, Adobe, and Pfizer use AI internally to build software, the most successful employees using AI are actually not necessarily coders or people with CS degrees,” David Hsu, CEO and founder of Retool, a business software builder, told Fortune. “Instead, they are just increasingly people in roles like sales, operations, and finance who learn to use the powerful AI-powered coding tools that exist today to create powerful apps.”

Degrees are evolving

Some experts argue that education is even more paramount in the age of AI.

“Anyone can prompt an AI tool to generate a block of code, but knowing whether that code is efficient, secure, and ethical requires human insight,” Dana Stephenson, CEO at Riipen, a platform that connects students with experiential learning through real work projects from industry partners, told Fortune. “A student might prompt an AI to build a simple app, but without training in software architecture, debugging, and responsible data use, they risk creating something fragile or even harmful.”

Anant Agarwal, Chief Academic Officer at 2U, an educational technology company that contracts with nonprofit colleges and universities to develop online programs, told Fortune that as AI develops rapidly, the skills it demands are appearing in jobs across industries more than ever. 

“In this environment, learning deeply and building real expertise is more important than ever because the AI roles and applications are in the context of these other fields,” Agarwal, who is also an electrical engineering and computer science professor at MIT, said. “Degrees also future-proof your career by preparing you for the next big technology, whatever it might be.”

When it comes to coding LLMs or building agentic AI applications, degrees are still needed to provide a rigorous foundation in math and computer science necessary to truly understand how the systems work, Agarwal added.

“At the same time, the four-year degree is evolving,” Agarwal said. “People are increasingly combining certifications and online programs to create flexible, personalized learning paths. Degrees still matter, but how we earn them is becoming more adaptable, modular, and directly tied to the skills the market actually wants.”

Fortune Global Forum

returns Oct. 26–27, 2025 in Riyadh. CEOs and global leaders will gather for a dynamic, invitation-only event shaping the future of business.

Apply for an invitation.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

大学教育 Gen Z AI 职业规划 技能优先 教育转型 College Education Gen Z AI Career Planning Skills First Education Transformation
相关文章