Fortune | FORTUNE 08月11日
Trump’s regulatory reset leaves crypto privacy tools like Tornado Cash in the lurch
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

本文探讨了Tornado Cash虚拟货币混合器被美国财政部制裁后引发的一系列法律和哲学难题。该工具允许用户匿名化加密货币,但也成为非法活动者的温床。文章聚焦于Tornado Cash创始人Roman Storm面临的法律诉讼,以及此案如何触及了代码是否能被制裁、政府干预个人数字现金权利等核心争议。尽管加密行业许多重量级人物支持Storm,认为此案侵蚀了隐私保护软件的理念,但Storm最终因经营无证货币传输业务被判有罪。此案的判决对未来隐私软件的发展可能产生深远影响,尤其是在“监管靠起诉”的背景下,核心指控——开发者对非托管软件的责任——得以延续。

⚖️ Tornado Cash事件引发了关于代码是否能被制裁以及政府是否应干预个人数字现金权利的争议。作为一种虚拟货币混合器,Tornado Cash允许用户匿名化其加密货币,但同时也成为了恐怖组织和黑客的工具,这使得美国财政部对其进行制裁,并随后引发了法律上的新问题。

🛡️ 尽管Tornado Cash的创始人Roman Storm因经营无证货币传输业务被判有罪,但许多加密行业的重量级支持者,包括Paradigm等风险投资公司,仍坚决维护其立场。他们认为,政府对Storm的起诉侵蚀了隐私保护软件的理念,并与财政部金融犯罪部门此前的指导意见相悖。

⚖️ Storm案的判决结果,特别是关于开发者对非托管软件责任的核心指控得以延续,为未来隐私软件的发展设定了一个可能危险的先例。尽管特朗普政府在其他方面对加密行业采取了较为宽松的监管态度,但这一案件表明,并非所有与加密货币相关的法律挑战都已“摆上桌面”。

I joined Fortune in August 2022, the same month that the U.S. Treasury Department sanctioned Tornado Cash, a virtual currency mixer that allowed users to input their (very traceable) cryptocurrency holdings and receive an anonymous output. The software, predictably, became a favorite of terrorist organizations and North Korean-affiliated hacking groups, but it also embodied the cypherpunk ideology that birthed the crypto sector.

OFAC’s action created novel questions, such as whether a piece of code, rather than a person or organization, can be sanctioned. It also drew the ire of privacy advocates, who argued that internet users should have the right to own and send digital cash without government interference, just as offline people can with physical cash (to a degree). These, more than crypto bros trying to drive up the price of their tokens through sex toy-related stunts, are the fascinating dilemmas raised by blockchain technology, and what sets it apart from other forms of financial technology. (And as much as I hoped topics like Tornado Cash would dominate my coverage, Sam Bankman-Fried’s FTX empire collapsed two months later.) 

A year after the sanctions, the Department of Justice brought charges against the creators of Tornado Cash, with one, Roman Storm, arrested in the United States. This was a tricky case for the crypto industry to get behind. The DOJ’s indictment made clear that the founders knew their software’s main utility was to help money launderers, including North Korea’s Lazarus Group, and they were earning millions of dollars off the platform through their own proprietary token. In a recurring segment I like to call “Are you taking notes on a criminal f***ing conspiracy,” one founder admitted over text that they had to relinquish control over the software to make it seem like they weren’t the owners. As one former DOJ prosecutor told me at the time, “These are pretty egregious facts.” 

But many powerful voices in the crypto industry, including the venture giant Paradigm, still threw their weight behind Storm, arguing that the government’s case eroded the idea of privacy-preserving software and was in direct contradiction to previous guidance issued by the financial crimes division of the Treasury Department. 

Storm’s initial trial, which was held in the same courthouse that hosted Bankman-Fried, wrapped up last week. Though he avoided two of the more serious charges, the jury still found him guilty on one, related to operating an unlicensed money transmitting business. His advocates are vowing to fight it, arguing that the decision sets a dangerous precedent for the future of privacy software. 

The more interesting question is why the case was allowed to continue under the Trump administration, which has broadly embraced the crypto sector—or at least the elements more tied to financial gains. The Securities and Exchange Commission abandoned cases against Coinbase and Justin Sun, and the DOJ issued a memo announcing the end of “regulation by prosecution” against the blockchain industry. They even dropped one of the lesser charges against Storm about registration. But the core charge—that a developer should be responsible for non-custodial software—was allowed to continue. 

The refrain since Trump returned to office has been that, thanks to the lax new regulatory approach, crypto enforcement is off the table. Unfortunately for Storm, it seems that’s restricted to memecoins.   

Leo Schwartz
X:
@leomschwartz
Email: leo.schwartz@fortune.com

Submit a deal for the Term Sheet newsletter here.

Joey Abrams curated the deals section of today’s newsletter. Subscribe here.

VENTURE DEALS

- BinSentry, a Kitchener, Ontario-based AI-powered agriculture technology company, raised $50 million in Series C funding. Lead Edge Capital led the round. 

- Casap, a San Francisco-based developer of automation technology for dispute and fraud cases, raised $25 million in Series A funding. Emergence Capital led the round and was joined by Lightspeed Venture Partners, Primary Venture Partners, SoFi, and others

PRIVATE EQUITY

- Datasite, backed by CapVest Partners, acquired Sourcescrub, a San Francisco-based provider of deal-sourcing data and workflows. Financial terms were not disclosed.

- HG Insights, backed by Riverwood Capital Investors, acquired Madkudu, a Mountain View, Calif.-based provider of GTM Solutions. Financial terms were not disclosed. 

- Jenmar, a portfolio company of FalconPoint Partners, acquired Weber Mining & Tunnelling SAS, a Rouhling, France-based developer of resins and foams for mining processes. Financial terms were not disclosed.

- Schneider Geospatial, a portfolio company of Align Capital Partners, acquired Full Circle Technologies, a Boston, Mass.-based permitting & licensing software company. Financial terms were not disclosed.

EXITS

- SentinelOne agreed to acquire Prompt Security, a New York City-based AI-powered cybersecurity platform, from Jump Capital.

OTHER

- 10x Genomics agreed to acquire Scale Biosciences, a San Diego, Calif.-based single-cell analysis company. Financial terms were not disclosed. 

This is the web version of Term Sheet, a daily newsletter on the biggest deals and dealmakers in venture capital and private equity.

Sign up

for free.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

Tornado Cash 加密货币 隐私权 法律制裁 区块链
相关文章