Fortune | FORTUNE 08月06日
DOGE cuts ‘act like a corrosive’ on labor stats revisions and U.S. economy, warns Moody’s Mark Zandi
index_new5.html
../../../zaker_core/zaker_tpl_static/wap/tpl_guoji1.html

 

文章探讨了Elon Musk推行的“政府效率部门”(DOGE)改革对美国就业数据和经济增长产生的连锁反应。改革导致政府部门裁员,这些裁员数据由于报告滞后,使得初期的就业估算出现较大偏差,并导致了就业数据的向下修正,引起了总统的关注和劳工统计局局长的解雇。经济学家Mark Zandi指出,DOGE的削减不仅影响了就业报告的准确性,也因统计机构人员减少而加剧了数据处理的延误。此外,DOGE改革还对第二季度GDP增长造成了约0.3个百分点的负面影响,预计未来政府非国防支出将持续下降。Zandi认为,持续的DOGE削减增加了经济衰退的风险,并警示裁员可能损害政府关键服务质量,如天气预报和食品安全检查。

DOGE(政府效率部门)的改革导致政府部门裁员,这些裁员由于报告的滞后性,使得初期的就业数据估算不准确,并最终导致就业数据的向下修正,引发了总统对就业形势的担忧和对劳工统计局局长的解雇。

经济学家Mark Zandi指出,政府部门裁员的增加,特别是统计机构(如劳工统计局BLS)人员的减少,不仅影响了就业数据的及时报告,还因处理流程的延误而加大了后续数据修正的幅度,从而降低了就业统计的准确性。

DOGE改革对经济增长产生了直接影响,第二季度美国GDP增长被削减了约0.3个百分点,主要原因是联邦非国防支出的显著下降。预计未来政府非国防支出将继续维持低位,对经济增长构成压力。

持续的DOGE削减被认为增加了美国经济衰退的可能性,其影响更像是“腐蚀”而非“悬崖效应”,即通过逐渐削弱经济基础而非制造突发性冲击来引发衰退。

除了经济数据的影响,DOGE改革带来的政府部门裁员还可能损害关键的政府服务质量,例如天气预报、食品安全检查等,这些服务对保障公共安全和福祉至关重要,其质量下降将带来广泛的负面影响。

Elon Musk’s DOGE may have completed much of its work in the federal bureaucracy, but the trickle-down effect from Musk’s chainsaw contributed to the downward employment revisions that drew President Trump’s ire and led to the now-infamous firing of the labor statistics commissioner.

The DOGE’s cuts to government jobs are contributing to downward employment revisions because the government typically reports its payrolls to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) late, and increasingly later reports often lead to bigger revisions, Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics, told Fortune. He noted that the government does not report in time for the initial employment estimate provided by the BLS.

“This didn’t matter much when government employment was stable, but now that government jobs are declining, the cuts are being picked up in the revisions,” Zandi said. He added that DOGE’s impact also extends to the statistical agencies themselves, including the BLS, where staff reductions slow the processing of employment records and lead to larger subsequent revisions.

According to the BLS, July’s employment report (released Aug. 1) showed a modest addition of 73,000 jobs. More strikingly, job gains from May and June were sharply revised downward by a combined 258,000. With employment rising by only 19,000 in May and 14,000 in June, the three-month average payroll growth dropped to just 35,000—down from 123,000 a year earlier.

Amid intensifying scrutiny over deteriorating employment figures, President Trump on Aug. 1 ordered the firing of Erika McEntarfer, the commissioner of the BLS.

Regarding the economy, Pantheon Macroeconomics found that DOGE cuts knocked approximately 0.3 percentage points from U.S. GDP growth in Q2, primarily due to an 11.2% drop in federal non-defense spending—a direct result of DOGE (Department of Government Efficiency) reductions. Analysts believe government spending will remain roughly flat in Q3, as small gains in state, local, and defense spending are offset by a further 5-to-10% drop in the federal non-defense component.

Zandi believes sustained DOGE cuts increase the odds of a recession. “The DOGE cuts likely act more like a corrosive on the economy than a cliff event, resulting in recession,” he said. Meanwhile, policies like higher tariffs or restrictive immigration rules would likely have a much more sudden and damaging impact on the economy, potentially causing a recession directly, Zandi said.

Beyond the numbers, Zandi flagged deeper risks stemming from DOGE’s workforce reductions. He warned that slashing jobs at statistical agencies is already degrading the quality of federal data—a symptom of wider unintended consequences for government services.

“Government workers have important jobs that are critical to providing important services to taxpayers,” Zandi said. “If jobs are cut and those services aren’t provided or aren’t provided in a timely and competent way, there can be significant negative fallout.”

He cited examples ranging from weather reporting vital to disaster response to food-safety inspections that safeguard the national food supply.

Introducing the 2025 Fortune 500

, the definitive ranking of the biggest companies in America. 

Explore this year's list.

Fish AI Reader

Fish AI Reader

AI辅助创作,多种专业模板,深度分析,高质量内容生成。从观点提取到深度思考,FishAI为您提供全方位的创作支持。新版本引入自定义参数,让您的创作更加个性化和精准。

FishAI

FishAI

鱼阅,AI 时代的下一个智能信息助手,助你摆脱信息焦虑

联系邮箱 441953276@qq.com

相关标签

DOGE改革 就业数据 经济增长 政府效率 衰退风险
相关文章